I didn't get into Bravo's downmarket
Project Runway replacement,
The Fashion Show, initially, but the past few days work, migraine nonsense and apartment cleaning have conspired to keep me home, flipping channels and willing to get crazy. So I'm caught up on
The Fashion Show, partly because I set my DVR to record it before I realized I wasn't interested, and partly because Bravo loves reruns.
The Fashion Show should be better than it is, primarily because of Isaac Mizrahi, but there is too much wrong with the show for him to overcome it.
Issue one: Kelly Rowland. Jesus Christ, what is this woman doing here? What, precisely, are her fashion credentials supposed to be? This bugs me in the same way that I am supposed to buy Katie Holmes as a "fashion icon." Kelly certainly wears clothes beautifully and I am sure she has worn a number of exceptional pieces in her lifetime, but
also. So I guess my question is, where does Kelly Rowland get off giving the contestants advice about their designs? Because it comes off more as Kelly's opinion about what Kelly would like to wear rather than the sort of high-level fashion critique offered by someone like, say, Tim Gunn. And really...unless you brought along a
Bedazzler, you're kind of fucked. She's fine as a hostess – maybe even a judge, I suppose she knows a thing or two about how to dress for the red carpet, but
then again – but I don't understand what she's doing in a mentor-type role. Which brings us to...
Issue two: Muddying of the mentor/contestant relationship.
Project Runway is really the only show that gets this right: Tim Gunn introduces the challenges/tasks to the contestants, he checks on their progress and offers guidance and advice, and then is
nowhere to be found when the judging takes place. Likewise, the judges see the garments as a whole, not – as Isaac and Kelly sometimes do – as the toned-down product of a much more ambitious initial vision or as a totally different garment than originally intended. Even
Top Model gets this simple concept half-right, with Jay Manuel present at photo shoots but absent at judging (although Jay Alexander is both mentor and judge). Why is Isaac checking on the contestants halfway through the process? Why is Kelly tagging along, sneering and poking at half-finished outfits she has no business weighing in on? Does Kelly sketch? Sew? Cut patterns? Study or know fashion history? THEN WHY IS SHE INFLUENCING THE GARMENTS IN PROCESS.
Issue three: Hopelessly tight deadlines and other limitations. I hate the
Harper's Bazaar mini-challenge. A bitchy lady from
Bazaar is in charge of it, and always delivers news of the assignment in a tone that suggests she expects very little of the contestants (though to be fair...this is usually borne out by the results). The designers usually have anywhere from 30 to 90 minutes to MAKE A GARMENT or DESIGN AND MAKE A SHOE or something else that can't possibly be done satisfactorily in the allotted time. The elimination challenges have correspondingly tight deadlines, which just means that almost everything on the runway looks at least a little bit ill-fitting. In fact, when somebody actually manages to make a pair of pants look decent, you have to imagine they are the best fashion designer on the face of the earth.
Issue four: The contestants. When compared to the
Project Runway designers, they are, as a whole, less talented, less entertaining, more childish, more weird. Reco is not just self-assured, he has a comically (and unreasonably) inflated ego. Daniella is not just competitive, she's bitchy and cold. Merlin is not just flamboyant, he's a clown. The bottom line is that there is no one to like and no one to hate but plenty of people to pity, which isn't fun at all. On reality television you can be a prick but you can't be a boring prick or a sad-sack prick.
Issue five: It's still too much like
Project Runway. It's actually comical – the contestants might as well be staying in the Atlas apartments and sending their models to the L'Oreal Paris hair and makeup room for all the similarities to the original.
The Fashion Show is just too plainly an imitation, and it's insulting to the viewers Bravo obviously hopes will be too lazy to turn the channel. They kept the worst parts – team challenges, opinions of pretty starlets handed down in the guise of wisdom, painfully clunky product placement – and jettisoned what worked: the personalities, which unfortunately can't be copied or imitated effectively.
Mizrahi, for one, deserves better. I can't see
The Fashion Show coming back for another season since it's neither as good as
Project Runway or as awful as something along the lines of
Bridezillas. Frankly I'd like to see a fashion-oriented show that revolves around Kelly Cutrone. Everyone except her would be super uncomfortable all the time and it would be fabulous.